Case Summary: Skidmore Camm Garrett v. Jona McKeehan Garrett
BY ARCHIE CULLEN, AM, MSF AND BRYAN ENDRES
The following article was prepared by its author(s). The opinions expressed in the article represent the author(s)’s and may not reflect the view and/or opinion of Vallit Advisors and its staff. Views/opinions are based on the specific facts and circumstances of each Matter.
This article analyzes Skidmore Camm Garrett v. Jona McKeehan Garrett, in which the Court of Appeals of Tennessee addressed whether a sole-owner financial advisory firm included transferable enterprise goodwill in a divorce valuation. The court affirmed that enterprise goodwill may exist alongside personal goodwill where recurring revenue streams are transferable, and held that an income approach, rather than an asset approach, appropriately captures such value, with client retention risk addressed through discount rates and marketability adjustments.
Introduction
In Skidmore Camm Garrett v. Jona McKeehan Garrett, the Court of Appeals of Tennessee considered the proper valuation of a sole-owner financial advisory firm, CLG Wealth Management, LLC, (“CLG”) in the context of equitable distribution in a divorce proceeding, with the central dispute focused on whether the business’s value was attributable solely to non-divisible personal goodwill or whether it also included divisible enterprise goodwill.
Background and Competing Valuation Positions
Husband’s Position
The husband’s expert characterized the business as entirely dependent on the husband’s personal relationships and reputation, emphasizing that clients were sourced through his personal network and arguing that a buyer could not realistically retain those relationships without his continued involvement. Based on this view, the expert concluded that the business contained no enterprise goodwill and instead consisted entirely of personal goodwill, resulting in a valuation limited to tangible assets using a net asset value method under the asset approach.
Wife’s Position
In contrast, the wife’s expert recognized the importance of the husband’s personal involvement but concluded that the business nevertheless possessed transferable enterprise goodwill, specifically in the form of recurring advisory fees and servicing trail income. According to this expert, a hypothetical buyer would acquire access to the existing client base and the associated revenue stream, even if client retention was not guaranteed, and that risk of attrition could be addressed through appropriate valuation adjustments rather than eliminating goodwill entirely.
Trial Court Findings
The central question before the court was whether CLG’s value consisted solely of personal goodwill tied to the husband or whether the business also included enterprise goodwill capable of transfer to a hypothetical buyer.
The trial court accepted the wife’s expert’s analysis and determined that the business possessed enterprise goodwill in addition to personal goodwill, placing particular emphasis on the existence of recurring revenue streams that could be transferred to a buyer. The court rejected the net asset value method as insufficient because it failed to capture the business’s income-producing capacity and instead adopted an income-based approach that reflected the expected future earnings of the business, adjusted for risk and marketability. The court ultimately concluded that CLG had significant value beyond its tangible assets and awarded one-half of that value to the wife as part of the marital estate.
Appellate Court Analysis and Application to Personal Goodwill Analyses in Valuation
The Court of Appeals of Tennessee affirmed the trial court’s decision and provided several key clarifications regarding goodwill in closely held professional service businesses:
Enterprise Goodwill May Exist in Sole-Owner Practices
The court declined to adopt a categorical rule that sole proprietorships or single-member entities lack enterprise goodwill. Instead, the existence of enterprise goodwill depends on the specific economic characteristics of the business, not merely its ownership structure.
Transferability of Revenue Stream Is Determinative
The court emphasized that enterprise goodwill may exist where a buyer can obtain access to the revenue stream and client relationships. Even if there is no guarantee of retention, the opportunity to generate future income can still have value.
Personal and Enterprise Goodwill Can Coexist
Although the husband’s personal relationships were a significant driver of the business, the court accepted that personal goodwill does not preclude the existence of enterprise goodwill. The appropriate approach is to distinguish and value the transferable component of the business.
Risk Adjustments Address Uncertainty, Not Existence of Goodwill
The court agreed that uncertainty regarding client retention does not eliminate enterprise goodwill and instead it is addressed through the use of discount rates and marketability adjustments.
Income Approach Properly Captures Enterprise Goodwill
The court found that the income approach better reflects the economic reality of recurring revenue businesses, appropriately captures intangible value derived from future earnings, and was more suitable than the net asset value method, which failed to incorporate intangible income-producing capacity.
Summary and Conclusion
In affirming the trial court, the appellate court underscored that personal goodwill and enterprise goodwill are not mutually exclusive and may coexist within a single professional practice, and that the appropriate valuation question is whether a portion of the business’s earnings can be attributed to a transferable income stream rather than solely to the individual owner. Accordingly, the court concluded that the income approach appropriately captured the enterprise component of goodwill in this case, while the net asset value method failed to reflect the economic reality of a business generating recurring, income-producing relationships.
Archibald Cullen, AM, MSF is a Supervisor with Vallit Advisors, LLC. Mr. Cullen provides support on business valuation, forensic accounting, and dispute advisory engagements. He is an Accredited Member (AM) with the American Society of Appraisers and holds a Master of Science in Finance (MSF) degree from American University. He also assists the Senior Management in the development of analyses and report preparation for a variety of cases. Mr. Cullen can be reached at 443-482-9500 Ext 121 or acullen@vallitadvisors.com
Bryan Endres is a Senior Analyst with Vallit Advisors, LLC and primarily focuses on providing dispute advisory, business valuation, and forensic accounting services for our clients. In addition, Mr. Endres has authored multiple articles on valuation topics, including works published in peer-reviewed journals and as part of Vallit Viewpoints. Mr. Endres can be reached at 443-482-9500 Ext 108 or bendres@vallitadvisors.com
The contents above are purely educational in nature. The information contained within the website of Vallit Advisors, LLC should not be assumed to be representative of the views and opinions held by Vallit Advisors, LLC. Information found on this website is not intended to be legal advice, it is not intended to create or solicit instructions of any kind and should not be treated as such. By accessing this web site, you are agreeing to be bound by the web site Terms and Conditions of Use.
Providing a Clear View of The Financial Picture
Vallit is focused solely on dispute consulting, business valuation and forensic accounting. Our senior team members have testified approximately 400 times in Federal, State and International courts. Our dispute expertise ranges from family law to complex commercial and intellectual property matters in a wide variety of industries. In non-disputes, our valuation reports are relied on by estate and trust attorneys, auditors, and business decision makers for tax, financial reporting and transaction purposes.