The Lost Profits Playbook: Mitigation Matters and How Efforts to Reduce Harm Impact Lost Profits Damages [Part 2 of 6]
BY ANDREW ROPER
The preceding article was prepared by its author. The opinions expressed in the article represent the author’s and may not reflect the view and/or opinion of Vallit Advisors and its staff. Views/opinions are based on the specific facts and circumstances of each Matter.
Andrew Roper, CPA, CFE is a Manager with Vallit Advisors, LLC. Andrew has over 8 years of experience in dispute consulting, lost profit and loss of value calculations, complex damage measurements, and other litigation services. He is a Certified Public Accountant (CPA) with the Virginia Board of Accountancy and a Certified Fraud Examiner (CFE) with the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners.
Vallit Viewpoints
Mitigation of damages is one of the most frequently litigated aspects of lost profits claims. Courts expect businesses to take reasonable steps to reduce losses, and the success or failure of those efforts can significantly influence the size of a damages award. This article examines the role of mitigation in lost profits cases, explaining common strategies businesses employ, including operational adjustments, revenue substitution, and financial restructuring. It also explores how to effectively evaluate and present evidence of mitigation, the disputes that often arise in litigation, and practical takeaways for both plaintiffs and defendants. By understanding how mitigation interacts with damages calculations, damages analysts can better prepare their analyses and strengthen the credibility of their lost profits conclusions.
Introduction
In our previous article, we introduced the fundamentals of lost profits damages and compared the different approaches for quantifying them. At the core of any lost profits analysis, however, is a simple question: what would the damaged business have earned but for the alleged wrongful act?
Answering that question requires more than just projecting losses. Courts expect parties to demonstrate not only what was lost, but also what could reasonably have been avoided. This expectation is where the principle of mitigation comes into play.
A plaintiff cannot passively accept losses and then recover the full amount from the defendant. Instead, it must act in a commercially reasonable way to minimize harm. Failing to do so can substantially reduce or even eliminate the damages awarded.
Understanding mitigation is critical. It influences how damages are calculated, the credibility of the claim, and the overall litigation strategy. In this article, we explore the duty to mitigate, common strategies businesses use to reduce losses, how mitigation impacts lost profits calculations, and the types of disputes that often arise around this issue.
Principles of Mitigation
The concept of mitigation is a cornerstone of damages law. In commercial disputes, it is generally accepted that a plaintiff cannot recover losses that could have been avoided through reasonable efforts.
At a base level, Mitigation is an action taken by a plaintiff to lessen or avoid loss from a wrongful act.1
The “mitigation-of-damages doctrine” is defined in Black’s Law Dictionary as:
“The principle requiring a plaintiff, after an injury or breach of contract, to make reasonable efforts to alleviate the effects of the injury or breach. If the defendant can show that the plaintiff failed to mitigate damages, the plaintiff’s recovery may be reduced.”2
While certain jurisdictions might use different terminology to describe this concept, such as the “avoidable consequences doctrine” in California,3 or the “avoidability of damages theory” in Florida,4 the core concept is a legal principle where a plaintiff must mitigate their damages and take “reasonable, non-burdensome steps to avoid its loss.”5
This principle, often referred to as the “duty to mitigate,” does not require the damaged party to go to extraordinary lengths or take on excessive risk. Instead, it sets a standard of commercial reasonableness in mitigating damages. Thompson Reuters Legal defines commercially reasonable efforts as “efforts ‘conducted in good faith and in accordance with commonly accepted commercial practice.'”6 In short, these efforts reflect actions that a prudent business would take under similar circumstances. When a plaintiff takes reasonable steps to reduce damages after a breach or wrongful act, there are two categories of efforts taken to mitigate damages in lost profits: negative efforts or affirmative efforts.
Negative efforts to mitigate damages would typically require a plaintiff taking steps to minimize its loss. For example, if a company experiences a business interruption, negative efforts would be to scale back operations to minimize losses.7
Affirmative efforts, on the other hand, seek to mitigate efforts through alternate means of generating revenue. For example, if a supplier fails to deliver raw materials, the injured business is expected to seek replacement sources, even if at somewhat higher cost. Similarly, if a client terminates a service contract, the service provider is expected to pursue other work rather than leaving its staff idle.8
The plaintiff’s duty to mitigate, however, does not absolve the defendant of liability. A defendant who breaches a contract or engages in wrongful conduct remains responsible for damages caused. However, the damages awarded are limited to those that could not have been reasonably avoided. Courts apply this standard to prevent overcompensation and to encourage efficient, practical responses to business disruption. For example, in Cypress Engine Accessories, LLC v. HDMS Ltd., HDMS filed a countersuit in which they claimed damages equal to the difference between the retail price of returned engine parts, less restocking fees and the wholesale price of the engine parts. However, the courts ruled that HDMS failed to mitigate damages by reselling returned engine parts at retail value and thus were not entitled to these damages.9
In Cambridge Plating Co., Inc., v. Napco, Inc., a district court noted that Cambridge Plating Co. had not mitigated their damages but did not adjust the damage award. However, an appellate court vacated and remanded the award due to Cambridge Plating Co.’s failure to mitigate.
By recognizing and applying this principle, courts ensure that lost profits damages reflect actual, sustainable harm—not avoidable or speculative losses.
Common Mitigation Strategies in Business Disputes
How a business responds to disruption often plays a decisive role in shaping the scope of recoverable damages. While no two situations are alike, several common strategies illustrate the types of steps courts expect companies to consider when mitigating lost profits.
Operational Adjustments
Businesses may seek to preserve profitability in numerous ways, including, but not limited to:
- shifting production schedules to prioritize high-margin or high-demand products when capacity is limited,
- temporarily reducing staffing hours or reallocating employees across business units,
- reworking or repurposing excess inventory for alternate uses or markets,
- leasing temporary equipment or warehouse space to maintain continuity of operations,
- deferring non-critical projects to free up resources for urgent needs, or
- altering purchasing practices or switching to secondary or backup suppliers, even if costs are higher.
For example, a manufacturer facing a material shortage might reallocate production capacity toward alternative product lines with available inputs. They might also reallocate employees to the alternative product line business unit and defer any non-critical projects to free up necessary resources to ensure that the reallocation of resources is prioritized. Operational adjustments made to preserve productivity are often the first and most immediate way businesses attempt to mitigate harm.
Revenue Substitution
When a contract or customer relationship is lost, companies are generally expected to pursue replacement opportunities. These opportunities could include:
- targeting new clients, customer segments, or adjacent industries,
- pivoting to alternative product or service offerings, such as restaurants that shifted to delivery & takeout options during the COVID-19 pandemic,
- diversifying geographically through e-commerce channels or other brick-and-mortar locations,
- offering smaller package sizes, lower-cost bundles, or reconfigured versions of existing products to appeal to price-sensitive customers,
- shifting to a subscription-based offering to stabilize cash flow during periods of volatility,
- repurposing existing assets to generate other forms of revenue, such as leasing unused equipment, facilities, or intellectual property (“IP”) to third parties for temporary revenue,
- licensing or developing monetization of IP to other companies when direct sales are constrained, or,
- entering into short-term distribution agreements with other firms to expand market reach.
Revenue substitution is not a one-size-fits-all solution to mitigate damages. It depends on the industry, business model flexibility, and available resources. Courts typically expect companies to explore reasonable alternatives, but as noted previously, they do not expect companies to pursue options that are speculative, impractical, or disproportionately costly.
Restructuring and Reallocation
When disruptions cause significant financial strain, businesses often turn to restructuring and reallocation strategies to preserve resources and stabilize operations. These actions don’t necessarily generate new revenue but help conserve cash and optimize resources to mitigate the scale of lost profits. Businesses may respond in different ways, including the following actions:
- cutting discretionary expenses such as marketing, travel or professional services,
- refinancing existing debt at lower interest rates to reduce financial pressure,
- negotiating payment deferrals or extended terms with lenders to improve short-term liquidity,
- renegotiating supplier contracts for lower minimum purchase requirements or more flexible terms,
- reallocating capital, labor, equipment or other resources from lower-priority projects to core revenue-generating activities,
- postponing capital expenditures or scaling down research & development (“R&D”) or long-term investments, or,
- outsourcing non-core functions temporarily to reduce fixed costs.
These restructuring and reallocation measures are particularly relevant in industries with large “fixed costs” (costs that remain consistent regardless of the amount of goods or services produced or sold), such as manufacturing, construction, hospitality, and transportation industries. By demonstrating active financial management in response to disruption, businesses show the court they took commercially reasonable steps to minimize losses, strengthening the credibility of their damages claim.
Insurance and Contractual Remedies
In some industries, insurance policies or contractual protections can offset losses. Business interruption insurance, warranty claims, or liquidated damages provisions may all serve as mitigation tools. While such remedies may not eliminate losses entirely, they can reduce the amount of damages attributable to the defendant.
Market Diversification
Companies with flexible business models may respond by expanding into new geographies, launching complementary products, or broadening their customer base. Diversification not only mitigates current harm but also strengthens long-term resilience.
Each of these strategies reflects the principle that a business should take reasonable and proactive steps to soften the impact of disruption. The specific actions taken depend on the nature of the business, the industry environment, and the resources available at the time of harm.
Impact on Lost Profits Calculations
Mitigation directly influences how lost profits are measured, as it narrows the gap between the “but-for” scenario (what the business expected to earn absent the wrongful act) and the “actual” scenario (what the business ultimately earned). In practice, this means damages experts must carefully evaluate which losses were truly unavoidable and which could have been reasonably reduced through mitigation.
At a fundamental level, mitigation is key in an expert’s calculation of lost profits. The continuation of the business and the ability for the plaintiff to be made whole require an effort for continuation to be made. Once the but-for profits are calculated, the expert will typically offset these profits against the actual, or mitigating, profits to calculate the lost profits.
Considerations Regarding Impact on Lost Profits Calculations
A few key considerations include:
Unavoidable vs. Avoidable Losses
Unavoidable losses remain part of the damages claim because no reasonable action would have prevented them. Avoidable losses, however, are excluded once evidence shows the business could have reduced them through commercially reasonable steps.
Cost and Effort of Mitigation
Plaintiffs are not required to undertake extreme measures, but they are expected to act prudently. Courts often weigh whether the costs of mitigation were proportionate to the expected benefits.
Partial Mitigation
Many cases involve partial mitigation—where losses were reduced but not eliminated. For example, a company that replaces a lost contract with a new one at lower profitability may still claim damages, but only for the difference in margin.
Illustrative Examples
It is helpful to consider how the efforts to mitigate might directly affect damage claims in specific examples.
For this exercise, let’s assume that a supplier breach prevents a manufacturer from fulfilling orders. If the manufacturer sources substitute materials at a higher price, the damages are limited to the additional cost incurred, and not the full revenue from lost sales.
Alternatively, the generation of additional revenues does not necessarily constitute mitigating revenues. For example, say a professional services firm loses a major client due to the actions of a vendor but replaces much of the lost revenue with a new engagement. While this might appear to be a straightforward deduction of mitigating profits from lost profits, the plaintiff might argue that they had the capacity to both perform the work for the major client as well as the new engagement. In this example, the plaintiff might consider showing how their but-for scenario would reasonably include revenues from both the new engagement as well as the major client that was lost.
In that specific example, however, this approach is not guaranteed to work without sufficient support. In Penncro Associates Inc. v. Sprint Spectrum PCS, the plaintiff’s contract with Sprint was breached by Sprint and the plaintiff subsequently took on work for AT&T and American Water. In their appeal, the plaintiff claimed that they were a “lost volume seller” and that they could have handled the new jobs and the work for Sprint. However, the appeals court noted that the district court had found that the plaintiff had the capacity for additional work only because of the breach of the Sprint contract and as such was not a “lost volume seller.”10
Alternatively, in Collins Entertainment v. Coats, the dispute centered around a broken six-year lease agreement for video poker machines. The defendant claimed that Collins Entertainment’s (“CE”) damages did not consider mitigating revenues from re-leasing the poker machines. Meanwhile, CE claimed that they had sufficient machines necessary to service both the Coats contract and other subsequent contracts. The courts found that while CE might have mitigating sales, they had sufficient machines necessary to fulfill both lost sales and mitigating sales, and thus any subsequent transactions did not qualify as a substitute or mitigation of lost sales.11
It is important to note that simply incurring unexpected costs in mitigation does not entitle a party to damages in the form of lost profits. One example involving mitigation of damages in a lost profits case is C&O Motors, Inc. v. General Motors Corporation. In this case, C&O Motors, Inc. (“C&O”) signed a five-year dealership agreement with General Motors Corporation (“GM”) to provide Oldsmobile vehicles at C&O’s dealership. Subsequent to the signing, GM decided to phase out its Oldsmobile line of vehicles from 2001 through 2004. When C&O learned that GM was phasing out the Oldsmobile vehicles, they purchased the rights to a Nissan dealership. C&O subsequently sued GM for damages including lost profits and the costs associated with acquiring the Nissan franchise. However, the court found that the profits generated by the Nissan dealership offset the lost profits claimed by C&O and that C&O had suffered no actual losses despite the breach of contract between GM and C&O.12
In short, mitigation shapes both the size and credibility of a lost profits claim. By carefully documenting how a business responded to the harm, financial experts can distinguish between losses that were truly unavoidable and those that could have been reduced, ensuring the damages analysis aligns with the court’s expectations.
Evidence of Mitigation Efforts
When assessing lost profits, documentation of mitigation efforts can be just as important as the financial records themselves. Courts require proof that the injured party acted reasonably in attempting to reduce damages, and the absence of such evidence can weaken or even discredit a claim.
Examples of Mitigation Evidence
Some of the most persuasive forms of evidence include:
Business Records and Communications
Emails, correspondence, and meeting notes showing attempts to secure replacement contracts, negotiate with alternative suppliers, or explore new markets.
Financial Documentation
Accounting records reflecting cost-cutting measures, shifts in production, or reduced expenses undertaken to offset lost revenue.
Market and Industry Data
Information demonstrating whether mitigation alternatives were realistically available. For example, showing that substitute materials were scarce industry-wide can support the argument that mitigation was limited.
Contracts and Agreements
Replacement agreements, temporary contracts, or purchase orders that show the business took proactive steps to substitute lost revenue or secure alternate supply sources.
Insurance Claims and Recoveries
Evidence of pursuing business interruption insurance or other contractual remedies, which may offset some portion of damages.
For experts, evaluating mitigation is not simply about whether steps were taken, but whether those steps were commercially reasonable given the circumstances. A company’s decision-making will often be judged in hindsight, but contemporaneous evidence showing timely, good-faith efforts can be decisive in establishing credibility and strengthening the damages claim.
Common Disputes Around Mitigation
While the principle of mitigation may seem straightforward, it is often a contested issue in lost profits litigation. Disagreements typically arise over whether the plaintiff’s response to the harm was reasonable, and how much those efforts should reduce the damages claim.
Common Disputes
Some of the most common disputes include:
Reasonableness of Alternatives
An argument that defendants might use is that plaintiffs could have pursued other opportunities to replace lost revenue. Meanwhile, the plaintiff would argue that the other alternatives were impractical, costly, or unavailable. For example, a retailer claims it could not source substitute inventory during a supply chain disruption, while the defendant points to competitors who did so successfully. In the preparation of a damages claim, it is important to consider other potential opportunities to replace the lost revenue and be prepared to support your decisions.
Timing of Mitigation Efforts
One thing that courts might consider is whether or not the plaintiff acted promptly in responding to the business disruption. Extended delays in seeking replacement suppliers, customers, or contracts can be viewed as a failure to mitigate. Acting promptly to mitigate efforts will be the ideal method for handling this dispute, but in the circumstance that mitigation efforts are delayed, it’s important to be prepared to explain why this was the case.
Extent of Mitigation
Even when some mitigation occurred, parties often dispute whether the plaintiff did “enough.” For instance, securing a partial replacement contract may reduce losses, but defendants may argue that further opportunities were available. It’s worth noting that this dispute is often up to the defense to prove, but the plaintiff should be prepared to address any claims that additional steps could have been taken.
Costs of Mitigation
Plaintiffs are not required to take steps that would be unreasonably expensive relative to the harm. However, disputes often center on whether the cost-benefit tradeoff was reasonable under the circumstances. Being able to support the decision-making process for the mitigation is helpful in these disputes.
Overstating Mitigation Efforts
Plaintiffs may emphasize proactive measures to strengthen their credibility, but experts and opposing counsel may challenge whether these steps were substantive or effective. Once again, being able to support the decision-making process for the mitigation efforts will be helpful in substantiating your claims.
In these disputes, expert testimony is critical. Financial experts help courts distinguish between avoidable losses that should not be recoverable and unavoidable losses that properly form the basis of a damages award. By examining contemporaneous evidence, industry conditions, and economic reasonableness, experts provide the framework courts rely on to evaluate mitigation disputes.
Practical Takeaways for Attorneys and Clients
Understanding and documenting mitigation efforts can make or break a lost profits claim. While the facts of each case vary, several practical lessons apply broadly to both plaintiffs and defendants:
For Plaintiffs
- Act quickly and reasonably to reduce harm; courts reward proactive behavior.
- Keep detailed records of all mitigation efforts, including communications, contracts, financial adjustments, and industry research.
- Be prepared to explain why certain alternatives were not pursued if challenged by the opposing side.
For Defendants
- Examine whether the plaintiff truly exhausted reasonable alternatives to reduce losses.
- Look for gaps in documentation, delays in response, or evidence of available substitute opportunities.
- Use expert analysis to highlight areas where damages could have been avoided.
For Both Sides
- Recognize that mitigation often narrows the damages gap significantly, changing the value of a case.
- Engage financial experts early to assess the reasonableness of mitigation actions (or inaction).
- Anticipate that mitigation will be a focal point of damages testimony and prepare accordingly.
By taking these steps, attorneys can strengthen their case strategy, and businesses can present a more credible and defensible position in litigation.
Summary and Conclusion
Mitigation is a fundamental element in lost profits damages that can dramatically reshape the outcome of a case. Courts expect businesses to respond to disruption in a commercially reasonable manner and actively take steps to reduce harm where possible. The size and credibility of the damages award is often impacted by the extent to which those efforts succeeded and the quality of the evidence supporting them.
For plaintiffs, strong documentation of mitigation efforts can enhance the persuasiveness of a lost profits claim. For defendants, carefully scrutinizing whether reasonable alternatives were overlooked can reduce potential exposure. For both sides, mitigation highlights the importance of engaging qualified experts who can assess the reasonableness of actions taken and quantify their impact on damages.
Ultimately, lost profits damages are not meant to overcompensate or punish. Rather, they are designed to make the injured party whole, consistent with what would have been earned absent the wrongful act. Mitigation ensures that this balance is preserved.
In the next article of our Lost Profits Playbook series, we will turn to another critical concept: reasonable certainty. We will examine what courts require when evaluating lost profits claims, the types of evidence that strengthen or weaken credibility, and how experts can help meet this legal standard.
References
1 FVS Practice Aid: Calculating Lost Profits, pg. 68.
2 Bryan A. Garner, Black’s Law Dictionary, Ninth Edition (2009), West Publishing Co., Thomas Reuters, United States of America, p. 1093.
3 State Dept. of Health Services v. Superior Court (McGinnis) (2003) 31 Cal.4th 1026.
4 Graphic Associates, Inc. v. Riviana Rest. Corp., 461 So.2d 1011, 1014 (Fla. 4th DCA 1984).
5 Koby v. United States, 53 Fed. Cl. 493, 496-97 (2002).
6 Chen, Lincoln. “Commercially reasonable efforts explained – Legal glossary,” 2024. Thomson Reuters. https://legal.thomsonreuters.com/blog/commercially-reasonable-efforts/
7 Lost Profits Damages “Mitigation of Damages in the Lost Profits Calculation,” by Scott M. Bouchner and Richard A. Pollack, pg. 347.
8 Ibid.
9 Cypress Engine Accessories, LC v. HDMS Ltd., USDC So. District of Texas, C.A. No. H-15-2227 (October 6, 2017).
10 Penncro Assocs., Inc. v. Sprint Spectrum, L.P., 499 F.3d 1151, 1155-56 (10th Cir. 2007).
11 Collins Entertainment v. Coats and Coats, 368 S.C. 410 (S.C. 2006).
12 C & O Motors, Inc. v. General Motors Corporation, U.S. Ct. Appeals, 4th Cir. No. 08-1157 (April 1, 2009).
The contents above are purely educational in nature. The information contained within the website of Vallit Advisors, LLC should not be assumed to be representative of the views and opinions held by Vallit Advisors, LLC. Information found on this website is not intended to be legal advice, it is not intended to create or solicit instructions of any kind and should not be treated as such. By accessing this web site, you are agreeing to be bound by the web site Terms and Conditions of Use.
Providing a Clear View of The Financial Picture
Vallit is focused solely on dispute consulting, business valuation and forensic accounting. Our senior team members have testified approximately 400 times in Federal, State and International courts. Our dispute expertise ranges from family law to complex commercial and intellectual property matters in a wide variety of industries. In non-disputes, our valuation reports are relied on by estate and trust attorneys, auditors, and business decision makers for tax, financial reporting and transaction purposes.